Would you return a wallet you found, let a cashier know if she made a mistake in your favour or do you use “finders keepers, losers weepers” as your motto?

My thirteen year old daughter and I were at the mall the other day. She asked if she could hold my cell phone. (Cell phones are a very big deal to my girls, especially since they are convinced that they are the only teens in Canada without a cell phone). I gave in and let her put my phone in her pocket.

When we got to the checkout line, I asked her to return my phone. It wasn’t in her pocket. She checked the other 372 pockets in her jacket (slight exaggeration, only slight). No phone. As I was contemplating retracing our steps through the store on the off-chance that we would find this teeny tiny marvel of the modern age, our cashier had a good idea. She suggested that I phone my phone to see if anyone would answer. Sound advice. I borrowed the phone at customer service and rang my own number. The familiar jingle began to emanate from my daughter’s coat sleeve! She won’t be getting her own phone any time soon.

I told this story to my hairdresser. The woman in the next chair said that she would have been surprised if a stranger would have returned my phone if we had lost it in the store. I told her that I think most people would. I would have. I’m sure that most of my friends would have. Are we in the minority these days?

Several times over the last few years, I have been the recipient of a cashier’s error in my favour. I thought perhaps that God was testing my integrity. I have always gone back to the store, explained the problem, and repaid the extra. This really freaks people out. Am I really such an oddity? One time, our grocery store had a case lot sale, and my cart was weighted down with all of the boxes. The cashier and I started yakking, and she forgot to take the boxes out to scan them. I thought that the amount seemed rather low for all the stuff I bought, but I didn’t figure out why until I got home. So I headed back with the list of all the things I didn’t get charged for and went to customer service and paid for about $60 worth of groceries.

I am not writing this to boast of my integrity (well, maybe a little), but rather to pose the question: “Would you have done the same?” Or have you been the recipient of a Good Samaritan’s generosity? Perhaps I am naive and too trusting of people. It could be that I would think differently if I were ever the victim of a crime. I hope that I would not change my thinking.

I don’t go through life worried about my stuff. Blissful ignorance, small town thinking, or stupidity? Take your pick. I’m sure that I have some of each.
I have given this topic at least forty-five minutes of intense self-reflection, and have come to the conclusion that at least part of it has something to do with a pay it forward, or random acts of kindness mentality. I had a watch that was stolen twice, and both times the perpetrator was found out and the watch returned to me. I have been in several accidents and had strangers stop to help me.

Perhaps the biggest reason that I trust people is that I first have an intense trust in God. I know that He is faithful, and that He has a whole lot of angels at His disposal, so that no matter what happens to me (or my stuff) in this life, God is still in control.

11
Liked it
Comments (9)
  • rutherfranc on Feb 6, 2009

    I think I am 98% of the time.. It`s the gift of being raised by God-fearing people.. 1% are white lies and 0.5% are secrets.. I withold my last % of honesty when it`s gonna hurt feelings. The temptation is always there (what if I don`t return it?) but I learned that I can`t sleep if I took advantage so I`d rather have the peace of mind.

  • Lee Altman on Feb 6, 2009

    It’s true the temtation is there. I have found a wallet with money and got in touch with the owner. He was from Canada and told me to keep the money.

  • AC Hamilton III on Feb 6, 2009

    Well, I have a few stories; Once I sent someone to buy little St Patrick’s decorations for the store where I was manager. When they came back, I counted one too many .29 cent decorations and made them take it back. They stared like a deer with headlights in the eyes. I called to make sure they did it, and got a long hush, then muffled whispers and giggles. Another time: I needed a stamp to mail something personal, my boss told me to just take one from the store. Ummm, nope; I put the money in the drawer for the stamp, and he thought I was a nut job, and almost pleaded for me to just take it. Lol! Yes, we are weird. I think a lot of people basically do the right thing. Nice article.

  • Anne Lyken Garner on Feb 8, 2009

    I clicked on this article the other day, but the link wasn’t working.

    This is a nice story. I’ve been stared at for returning things, or for making my kids return them (when they were toddlers, before they learned you had to pay for things).

    In England it’s very much a ‘finders-keepers’ sort of mentality, so people do not expect for things to be returned to them.

    At work, if I would like to use something (like a stamp), I would ask. If I’m told I can take it, I would. I wouldn’t refuse the offer of help, but I wouldn’t take things that are not mine.

    Everyone likes free stuff. I have found that if you ask, you *do* get offered lots of free stuff. However, I wouldn’t resort to keeping things I’ve found. I think that you’re right, we are in the minority.

    Once, about eight years ago, I found some money in a parking lot. I went into the store, and put up a sign to say that I had found something in a white envelope, (if I had said ‘money,’ everyone would’ve called. I figured the right person would know straight away) described where it was, and left my number.

    Three weeks later, the sign was still there, and no one had called. I eventually spent the money, but it still haunts me.

  • OhSugar on Feb 9, 2009

    We all know the right thing to do, when you find something as important as a lost wallet or other important item, but we don’t always allow our good sides to shine. I personally would be too afraid not to return the item, because I believe what goes around come around.

  • Christine Ramsay on Feb 9, 2009

    An interesting read. I think I mostly would do the right thing. You can’t take anything out of shops unpaid for here because of the scanning system. I would hate the buzzer to go off as I get to the door. I have returned things in the past. This has really made me think.

    Christine

  • Kate Smedley on Feb 13, 2009

    I am a great believer in the ‘pay it forward’ idea, unfortunately as Anne said, in England it can often be a ‘finders keepers’ approach. Thanks for a though provoking article.

  • Kate Smedley on Feb 13, 2009

    Sorry, I meant thought provoking!

  • C LEBLANC on Feb 20, 2009

    i always try to do the right thing. dont always get it perfect but try.

Leave a Comment

Hi there!

Hello! Welcome to Authspot, the spot for creative writing.
Read some stories and poems, and be sure to subscribe to our feed!

Find the Spot

Loading