Complete analysis of Theft.

In this story by Katherine Porter, the unnamed main character is a young woman who has a very nice purse that everyone envies; it is her most valuable possession because it was a gift from a friend.  Everyone in this story is very poor, which gives the moral of the story even greater meaning.  When the young woman puts her purse down in her room, the cleaning lady comes in to clean her room, but when the girl returns her purse is gone.  She confronts the janitor, who admits that she stole it so that she could give it to her niece for her seventeenth birthday and reluctantly gives it back to the girl.  When the main character, the young woman, decides to let the janitor can keep the purse, the janitor says that she doesn’t want it now because she can get something better for her nieces.  The tone of the story is ironic, showing how the janitor wanted the purse if she could steal it, but didn’t want it when it was given to her.  The story looks into the ontological questions “how important is money, is truth absolute or relative, and is a person inherently good, bad, or both?”

7
Liked it
Comments (12)
  • diamondpoet on Nov 12, 2009

    Nice story.

  • Googly Eyed on Apr 18, 2010

    This analysis lacks substance.

  • Anon on Apr 21, 2010

    Must every analysis contain quotes to provide substance? Read the story, then read the analysis. There\’s nothing transparent.

  • a high-er source on Apr 22, 2010

    what if you looked at it this way… what if the main character stole it herself? reread the story with that in mind. new things will stick out

  • Nashenas on Apr 28, 2010

    What is this ? IF analysis is to be like this I must leave studying literature.
    Repair It!!!!

  • bag charm on Apr 5, 2011

    like your share.

  • bag charm on Apr 5, 2011

    .like your share.

  • p on Apr 21, 2011

    this was a horrible understanding of the story.

  • Macie on Sep 30, 2011

    This analysis needs to actually analyze the story more. This told me absolutely nothing.

  • KD on Dec 2, 2011

    Bad, bad, bad. Totally missed the point.

  • Michael on Apr 17, 2012

    If the analysis is so bad. Can someone please tell me what the story is actually about then, with substance?

  • peo on May 26, 2012

    horrible i dont understand nothing read another time the story a redoit

Leave a Comment

Hi there!

Hello! Welcome to Authspot, the spot for creative writing.
Read some stories and poems, and be sure to subscribe to our feed!

Find the Spot

Loading